Beyond $10-a-day: A policy audit of Canada-Wide Early Learning and Childcare

Photo by Avin CP

Beyond $10-a-day: A policy audit of Canada-Wide Early Learning and Childcare is now available on the childcarecanada.org website.

The report is authored by Samama Butt, Research Analyst Professional Program, Humber Polytechnic, and Peivand Pirouzi Ph.D., Professor, Research Analyst Professional Program, Humber Polytechnic. The audit reports positively on the impact so far of the federal child care legislation, stating:

Canada-Wide Early Learning and Child Care (CWELCC) is one of the most consequential social-policy achievements in recent Canadian history, delivering a rapid and measurable reduction in the cost of regulated childcare for millions of families. This policy audit finds that CWELCC's affordability results, a national childcare price decline exceeding 31 percent between 2021 and 2025 against a rising all-items index, are substantive rather than symbolic, and are already visible in stronger parental labour-force participation and household financial security.

The pace of space expansion has understandably lagged the pace of demand growth that this very success generated, a sequencing dynamic rather than a design failure, and one that is common to nearly every jurisdiction that has attempted rapid childcare reform. Drawing on stakeholder, PESTEL, impact, and comparative international analyses, the article situates CWELCC's early results against Australia's subsidy-based model and Germany's legal-entitlement model and finds that Canada's federated, transfer-based approach compares favourably in the speed and scale of affordability delivery, even as all three systems continue working to match supply with demand.

The article proposes four complementary reforms, a national delivery compact, a protected workforce-stability reserve, a needs-based access and equity index, and a common performance system with corrective funding triggers, each designed to build on CWELCC's existing legal and intergovernmental architecture rather than to redesign it. These recommendations aim to consolidate and extend the policy's substantial early gains so that the historic affordability breakthrough already achieved is matched, over time, by equally strong operational access for every Canadian family.

The audit identifies four significant strengths in the existing model:

1. The affordability result is large, national, and durable. A 31% real decline in the childcare price index over four years, sustained across a change in federal budget cycles and dozens of provincial and territorial elections, is a rare degree of policy stability and follow-through (Canada Early Learning and Child Care Act, 2024; ESDC, 2026c).

2. The program has already produced a measurable labour-market effect. Labour-force participation among mothers of young children reached 79.5% in 2025, consistent with the policy's founding rationale that affordable care removes a structural barrier to parental employment (ESDC, 2026c).

3. The federal government has continued to invest at scale rather than retreating after the initial rollout, committing more than $58 billion since 2021 and a further $5.4 billion for 2026-27 and 2027-28 (ESDC, 2026b), which signals durable political commitment across jurisdictions of differing political composition.

4. The program has submitted itself to independent scrutiny. The Office of the Auditor General's 2025 review, and ESDC's own 2026 evaluation of the ELCC Innovation Program, demonstrate a level of transparency and willingness to identify gaps that is uncommon for a program still in its early implementation years (OAG, 2025; ESDC, 2026a). This audit culture is precisely the foundation on which the recommendations below can be built, since each proposed reform strengthens an accountability mechanism that already exists rather than creating one from scratch.

The audit makes the following four recommendations, all of which are”calibrated to be achievable within CWELCC’s existing legal and fiscal architecture. None requires renegotiating the foundational bilateral agreements or the Canada Early learning and Child Care Act, each can be implemented through the renewal cycle already underway”.

Establish a National Access, Workforce, and Equity Compact

The federal government should establish a National Access, Workforce, and Equity Compact under the National Advisory Council, supported by a permanent CWELCC Delivery Table. Membership should include federal, provincial, territorial, municipal, Indigenous, educator, provider, disability, official-language, settlement, and family representatives. Each jurisdiction should submit one integrated plan connecting operating funds, wages, capital, inclusion supports, local planning, and operational-space targets. Beginning in 2027-28, the table should review results twice yearly and publish unresolved barriers. This builds on existing legal and intergovernmental structures rather than creating a separate program.

Create a Protected Workforce-Stability Reserve

Renewed agreements should reserve a proposed 20% of the new two-year federal allocation, up to $1.08 billion of the $5.4 billion announced for 2026-27 and 2027-28, for workforce stability (ESDC, 2026b). Eligible measures should include wage grids, benefits, paid sick leave, planning time, practicum support, credential recognition, professional learning, and targeted rural and Indigenous workforce strategies. By March 2029, the national share of centres reporting ECE vacancies should fall from 35% to 20% or less, and benefit coverage should rise from 75.5% to at least 90% (Charters & Findlay, 2024). Australia's 21-action workforce strategy and dashboard provide a practical accountability model.

Allocate Expansion Through a Child Care Access and Equity Index

Governments should direct expansion through a Child Care Access and Equity Index. The index should combine child population, verified waitlists, infant demand, income, rurality, transportation, disability-related demand, official-language needs, newcomer settlement patterns, and non-standard schedules. A proposed 15% of the new two-year allocation, up to $810 million, should fund capital and start-up costs in the highest-need locations and service categories. At least 40% of remaining net space growth should occur in identified high-need areas. Germany's regional gaps show why national entitlements must be paired with local capacity evidence. Local authorities and Indigenous partners should validate priorities so provincial totals do not bypass communities with the weakest access.

Build a Common Performance System with Corrective Triggers

The federal government should reserve a proposed 1% of the new allocation, up to $54 million, for a common performance and data system led by ESDC and Statistics Canada with Indigenous data partners. It should publish results within nine months of year-end using common definitionsfor operational spaces, closures, waitlists, staffing, turnover, benefits, inclusion, flexible care, and fees. Data should be disaggregated by geography, income, family type, disability, newcomer-relevant indicators where appropriate, and official language, while Indigenous partners control their own indicators and governance. If a jurisdiction misses an access or workforce target by more than 10% for two consecutive reporting periods, 15% of its next new federal allocation should be redirected to the unmet constraint without increasing parent fees; a third miss should trigger an independent implementation review.